To the Editor:
As the shale gas rush has exploded over the last decade, so has the
number of reports of public health and environmental problems. The New
York Times and others have uncovered problems such as radioactive
fracking waste, drinking water contamination, air pollution and more.
Yet the controversy surrounding fracking isn’t because of an uninformed public, despite what David Brooks suggests in “Shale Gas Revolution”
(column, Nov. 4). It’s because of the shale gas industry’s reluctance
to address the serious risks surrounding drilling and its relentless
effort to oppose even the most minimal public health protections.
In 2005, the shale gas industry successfully persuaded Congress and the
Bush administration to exempt fracking from the Safe Drinking Water Act.
In 2009, the industry aggressively fought efforts by me and other
members of Congress to require that drilling companies publicly reveal
what chemicals they inject into the ground. And just this year, the
industry sought to narrow the Environmental Protection Agency’s study on
fracking’s risks to water resources.
If shale gas drilling is as safe as the industry would like us to
believe, then the drilling companies must be open and honest about the
injections they are jamming into the ground and should have no problem
complying with basic federal environmental laws.
MAURICE D. HINCHEY
Washington, Nov. 4, 2011
Washington, Nov. 4, 2011
The writer, a Democrat, represents the 22nd District in New York.
To the Editor:
But even if we switched all our coal-fired power plants to gas, swapping
out one source of carbon dioxide for another, we would still be warming
the planet at only a slightly less dangerous pace. Moreover, shale gas
operations today emit substantial methane, a global warming agent vastly
more potent than carbon dioxide.
If a switch to gas is to occur, it must be accompanied by
full-scale development and deployment of carbon capture and storage
technology for gas-fired power plants, and tough curbs on methane
pollution, or we will be taking unnecessary risks with the only
atmosphere we have.
ARMOND COHEN
Executive Director
Clean Air Task Force
Boston, Nov. 6, 2011
Executive Director
Clean Air Task Force
Boston, Nov. 6, 2011
No comments:
Post a Comment